3 Best Restaurants in Modica, Sicily

Accursio Ristorante

$$$$ Fodor's choice

This intimate Michelin-starred restaurant is a fantastic option if you are staying in Modica overnight. Forget the usual starchy tablecloths and formal service, this place is all about the food, with the chef cooking his own personal takes on classic Sicilian dishes, including options like trucioli pasta with cheese fondue, lemon, capers, and coffee; grilled lettuce with pork cheek, caviar, and walnuts; and cannoli with ricotta cheese and cotton candy for dessert. The €120 tasting menu comes very highly recommended, but for something more affordable, stop in for lunch to have a similar experience for €50, or consider Accursio Radici (which means Accursio Roots, the cheaper sister restaurant) a few doors down.

Via Grimaldi 41, Modica, Sicily, 97015, Italy
0932-941689
Known For
  • Michelin-starred food at reasonable prices
  • equally extensive and more affordable lunch menu
  • relaxed atmosphere
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed Mon. No dinner Sun.

Locanda del Colonnello

$$
In the higher reaches of Modica Alta, this Italian neo-bistro uses local ingredients to create deceptively simple dishes with unique flavor combinations—think sardine-stuffed ravioli and rabbit stew with broccoli—in a laid-back and inviting atmosphere. Whether you dine in the casual white interior or on the quiet patio, the attentive servers are happy to recommend creative menu items, paired with a reasonably priced wine from their primarily Sicilian list.
Via Blandini 5, Modica, Sicily, 97015, Italy
0932-752423
Known For
  • <PRO>creative combinations</PRO>
  • <PRO>good Sicilian wine selections</PRO>
  • <PRO>casual yet welcoming vibe</PRO>
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed Tues. and Feb.

Pasticceria Di Lorenzo

$

Wood-lined and unadorned, this family-run pastry shop is one of the best places to try Modica’s signature crescent-shape cookies, the ‘mpanatigghi. These soft cookies are filled with a mixture of chocolate, almonds, and veal, a combination that works surprisingly well. The meat was added to the cookies as a way of making the snacks more nutritious on long voyages. The shop is also known for its delicious chocolate squares that are modeled to look like the city’s cobblestones.

Corso Umberto I 225, Modica, Sicily, 97015, Italy
0932-945324
Known For
  • family-run
  • specialty cookies
  • chocolate squares that resemble the city's cobblestones
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed Wed.

Recommended Fodor's Video