6 Best Restaurants in New York City, New York

Avlee Greek Kitchen

$$ | Carroll Gardens
Authentic dishes and the use of top-grade products (olive oil, feta, freshly baked pita) are the reasons locals adore this restaurant. Start with the Prasini salad, a delicious blend of crisp romaine, dill, scallions, and a generous amount of the aforementioned salty cheese. The space is tight, and service can be slow during the busy dinner rush, but it’s worth the wait when you’re presented with a steaming plate of moussaka or haloumi cheese grilled to perfection.

Avra Rockefeller Center

$$$$ | Midtown West

Expect to find Greek cuisine that celebrates the sea as deliciously as a seaside taverna at Avra’s Midtown West location, across from Radio City Music Hall (there are two more Avra outposts on the east side). The starters menu features wonderfully fresh salads, housemate hummus, grilled or lightly fried calamari, halloumi, and an excellent raw bar and entrées include both “from the sea” and “from the land” items. All dishes showcase Avra’s fine ingredients, though its sashimi and ceviche menu sparkle most thanks to delicate additions like cucumber chimichurri, micro cilantro, and perfect amounts of Mediterranean olive oil and sea salt. The lofty dining room is a welcome respite along this busy commercial corridor, with patio seating in warmer months. Avra’s three-course lunchtime prix-fixe, served 11:30 am to 4:30 pm, may be Midtown’s best dining secret.

1271 6th Ave., New York, New York, 10020, USA
212-430--8888
Known For
  • authentic Greek specialties
  • unbeatable lunch menu
  • Mediterranean-sourced cheeses and fish

Elia Restaurant

$$$
Something of a Bay Ridge secret, Elia has been serving refined Greek delicacies in the neighborhood since 1998. The menu features grilled meat, fish, and seafood, as well as traditional casseroles and appetizers, all prepared with innovative touches: grilled shrimp, for example, are served with pomegranate couscous and avgolemono (egg-lemon sauce), and tender homemade ravioli are filled with braised lamb. The lamb shank baked in a clay pot with orzo is always a good bet.
8611 3rd Ave., Brooklyn, New York, 11209, USA
718-748--9891
Known For
  • whole fish
  • everything grilled, especially the octopus
  • warm Mediterranean vibe
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed Mon. No lunch

Recommended Fodor's Video

Nerai

$$$ | Midtown East

The restaurant's contemporary, upscale update on Greek dining presents Mediterranean flavors in an airy setting whose white tablecloths and walls evoke Greece. Greek hospitality dates back thousands of years, and is on display here with a knowledgeable and accommodating waitstaff and excellent service. Each dish is prepared with intention, from items on the raw bar to mains such as the lobster pasta and baby lamb chops; the gelato is a perfectly refreshing dessert. In warmer months, request a table in the expansive outdoor garden. 

55 E. 54th St., New York, New York, 10022, USA
212-759–5554
Known For
  • Greek wines
  • good raw bar
  • outdoor garden for seasonal dining
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: No lunch weekends

Pylos

$$$ | East Village

The perfect setting for a relaxed dinner or an intimate special occasion, this tastefully refined, light-filled East Village restaurant emphasizes rustic cooking from all over Greece. There are delicious versions of hearty comfort-food dishes like pastitsio and moussaka on the menu, but the lighter dishes—especially the fish options—let the flavors shine through. The extensive selection of interesting hot and cold mezes is a great place to start exploring. Accompany your meal with some vino from the all-Greek list; the light white Atlantis wine from the island of Santorini is enjoyable and affordable.

128 E. 7th St., New York, New York, 10009, USA
212-473–0220
Known For
  • elevated Greek fare
  • broad meze selection
  • clay-baked meat dishes
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: No lunch Mon., Tues.

Taverna Kyclades

$$$ | Astoria

The unassuming location and simple decor belie the elevated Greek classics served at this, the neighborhood's current powerhouse of Hellenic eats. Fried calamari, red snapper, and grilled octopus make appearances on the menu, as do more out-of-the-ordinary dishes like "caviar dip" and swordfish kebabs. Lamb chops drip with juice, and grilled sardines are so fresh, you'd swear they were just pulled from the sea. Be prepared to wait for a table at peak times, as this restaurant doesn't take reservations. There's also a Manhattan outpost on 1st Avenue and 13th Street in the East Village.

36--01 Ditmars Blvd., Queens, New York, 11105, USA
718-545–8666
Known For
  • most authentic Greek fare this side of the Acropolis
  • lamb chops
  • no reservations
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Reservations not accepted