7 Best Restaurants in Cape Cod, Massachusetts

Arnold's Lobster & Clam Bar

$$

You can't miss this hot spot on the side of Route 6: look for the riot of colorful flowers lining the road and the patient folks waiting in long lines for fried seafood and other fixings. Unusual for a clam shack like this is the full bar, offering beer, wine, mixed drinks, and the house specialty: margaritas. You can also play a round of minigolf.

Chez Antoine Café

$

Owner/baker Antoine Vera has brought the French and Belgian boulangerie experience to Hyannis with this charming cafe, located just steps from the Village Green. Order fair-trade coffee, tea, and a wonderful pastry—or perhaps a prosciutto and cheese sandwich—and enjoy conversation with a friend at one of the indoor or outdoor bistro tables. Before you leave, pick up a tin of Belgian cookies or a jar of French mustard to bring home, along with a few extra melt-in-your-mouth macarons.

Four Seas Ice Cream

$

Lining up for an ice cream cone or frappe at Four Seas, a former blacksmith shop near Craigville Beach, has been a rite of summer on the Cape since 1934; it made the ice cream for Caroline Kennedy's wedding (the flavor: fresh peach) and has won a bazillion 'best' awards. They also sell lobster salad rolls, hot dogs, and other sandwiches. 

360 S. Main St., Massachusetts, 02632, USA
508-775--1394
Known For
  • local institution since 1934
  • penuche pecan, a flavor they dreamed up
  • homemade fresh peach, strawberry, or cantelope ice cream
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: limited service Sept.--May

Recommended Fodor's Video

Katie's Ice Cream

$

Making small batch ice cream and pastries in-house daily, Katie's has a huge following for its delicious flavors, like the popular Cape Cod Mud, a concoction of coffee ice cream, chocolate, house-made fudge, roasted almonds, and chopped chocolate sandwich cookies. Try to figure out the secret recipe of the Cape Cod Sand ice cream, a hit since 2002, when it was developed by Katie’s younger brother Gene, but don't expect anyone to give it away. Cookies and other sweet treats are also available.

568 Main St., Massachusetts, 02601, USA
508-771--6889
Known For
  • creative flavors, like lavender honeycomb and ginger lemon cookie
  • friendly staff
  • offers both soft serve and hard-packed ice cream
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed early Oct.-mid-Apr.

Pie in the Sky Bakery & Cafe

$

Crowds line up for tasty treats at this beloved year-round bakery, in business since 1982, which serves up a lot more than pie, though that is not to be missed. Sticky buns and scones fly out of the kitchen at breakfast, while daily soup specials, wraps, and salads are popular at lunch.

PJ's Family Restaurant

$$$

For more than 50 years, this family-run seafood and ice cream shack has been serving hungry vacationers. It's a go-to joint for a quick post-beach dinner (or pre-beach lunch) with a menu that goes beyond the usual deep-fried items: Options include broiled seafood plates, hot and cold lobster rolls, and 15 different salads. Order dessert at the soft-serve ice-cream window. 

Sundae School

$
Churning out ice cream in small batches since 1976, this popular place usually has lines out the door. The shop uses only the freshest ingredients, so flavors like banana or blueberry are made with the real deal, but you can always count on the classics like vanilla and chocolate. You can also get frozen yogurt and frappes (milk shakes). There's another location in Dennis Port.